Home / US Education / Tim Scott Joins the "Banned by Diane" Brigade

Tim Scott Joins the "Banned by Diane" Brigade

It’s now not ceaselessly that the unofficial matriarch of anti-ed reform will get referred to as out for her toughen of the company schooling forces that she would, another way, have us consider that she opposes.  When it does occur, on the other hand, because it did a pair days in the past when Emily Talmage puzzled Diane’s fresh gush about the virtues of the MacArthur Foundation, Ravitch’s response is completely predictable: she accuses the ones with the temerity to query her skilled judgment or her coverage positions as “lashing out” with private assaults in opposition to her.    

It is Diane’s ruthless cultivation of sympathy amongst her fans, then, that takes the focal point off the questions raised about her positions and places it on the motives of the one who raises the questions.  In doing so, Ravitch transforms the skeptical questioner right into a mendacious meanie, whose grievance, then, can also be pushed aside outright.  

Ravitch, then, successfully makes use of the private assault technique that she attributes to others so as to neutralize any grievance of her personal positions, that are predictably aligned with DNC neoliberals and more and more out of contact with truth. 

You must pass to the Talmage web page first and browse the submit that has Diane’s Basecamp fans waving their limp swords at the imaginary attacker.  And then learn Ravitch’s reaction.  I believe you are going to see what I imply.

You may wish to learn the feedback as smartly at the Ravitch weblog.  Among them, Tim Scott posted the remark underneath: 

As I see it, the state-finance nexus (banks/monetary markets/firms; state, federal and municipal governments; NGOs; philanthrocapitalists; DNC/RNC; white supremacy, colonialism, militarized austerity, and many others.) that’s using Ed Reform 2.zero is maintained by duplicitous project statements, promotions, pronouncements, advertising and marketing agendas and ideological/cultural narratives. This profiteering internet of deceit additionally will depend on devoted pundits like Ravitch, who earnestly, implicitly and duplicitously advertise and normalize this schedule, whilst presenting themselves as benevolent brokers of the not unusual excellent.

That remark, in flip, raised Dr. Ravitch’s hackles even additional.  So a lot, in truth, that she has censored all additional remark from Dr. Scott (my bolds): 

One of the laws of the weblog is that I don’t submit feedback that insult me. The weblog is my front room, and I be expecting other people to behave with politeness, even supposing we debate, disagree, and hash out our variations. It is a full of life room, and I attempt to stay the dialog civil, which isn’t all the time simple. 

I’m making an exception on this case as it turns out to be useful for different readers to listen to your voice and remember that the ones people who combat privatization, high-stakes checking out, standardization, and the substitute of academics by algorithms don’t seem to be united. If you assume I’m your enemy, you might have an overly odd figuring out of what I’ve written in books, articles, and day-to-day blogs for the previous a number of years. 

Since you might have recognized me as an enemy of the purpose I combat for each day, I will be able to ask you now not to go back right here once more.

This, once more, is natural Ravitch: Use the quilt of civility to ruthlessly take away any opposition.

If you might have had your feedback censored by the Ravitch workforce at her weblog for being uncomfortably fair, ship us your offending feedback, and we can submit them right here for public scrutiny.  

About hassan

Check Also

ESSA Goes After NY Community High Schools

There are 51 of them in New York City, and so they serve switch scholars …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

%d bloggers like this: